Shedding Light on Granblue Fantasy’s Delay and A-1’s Struggles
The anime adaptation of the popular mobage Granblue Fantasy was detailed back in August 2016 as a TV series due winter season 2017. No actual information about it surfaced until Christmas, when they revealed that the winter date referred to a special one-time broadcast of an arc, and that the show proper would air next spring. A brave attempt at damage control, but hiding the truth isn’t easy.
Let me start by saying that this isn’t even being acknowledged as a delay. The news post a mere 3 weeks ago talks about the broadcast date having been established for April, with the exact same wording you’d see for any normal reveal – including Granblue’s original January broadcast one, still up on the site. This isn’t particularly surprising for a big Aniplex title; Cinderella Girls was quite obviously planned to air as two consecutive cours, something made obvious by the bluray release, and yet never mentioned when it was announced that it would be split in two halves between an Idolmaster rebroadcast as quite literal filler. Is there any proof of this or are we going to be left with the sneaking suspicion? Digging around a bit you can find the answer.
This is the Twitter profile of the always fantastic Masashi Ishihama, whose directional career is strongly linked to A-1. It mentions that he’s finishing the production of an opening sequence for spring.
And this was his Twitter profile until very recently, stating that he was working on an opening for January. With all shows where he could feasibly show up having already featured their openings and his work not having surfaced, plus his bond with A-1 being as strong as it is, this is just a matter of putting 1 and 1 together. Considering how late both the announcement and his profile change were (both during late December), the decision to postpone Granblue seems to have occurred at the very last-minute. This is further supported when you look at Saekano’s also late rebroadcast announcement, outside of the network it belongs to and with a lineup of channels that looks more like a new show premiere than a quick reair decision – chances are that those were the timeslots originally allotted to Granblue. Seeing these production issues hit this show in particular is also no surprise; Akira Takata was planned to be its chief animation director alongside Asami Komatsu, but she’s so busy (also acting as chief animation directorChief Animation Director (総作画監督, Sou Sakuga Kantoku): Often an overall credit that tends to be in the hands of the character designer, though as of late messy projects with multiple Chief ADs have increased in number; moreso than the regular animation directors, their job is to ensure the characters look like they're supposed to. Consistency is their goal, which they will enforce as much as they want (and can). on Blue Exorcist on the current season, all while still having Natsume Yujincho work!) that Yuki Imoto has been sneakily added to the list of series supervisors. It seems like Granblue’s is a story of poor planning spanning beyond the show itself.
I don’t want this post to seem harsh on delays. Au contraire, if anything that’s a desirable development for anime. In an industry where lack of time wrecks projects and hurts creators who were already working under poor conditions, TV shows getting pushed back is something positive. Of course that a solidly planned, sane project would have scheduled this show for spring to begin with, but having arrived to this point this is definitely the lesser evil; if you’re impatient and think you wanted a winter Granblue with 20 animation directors and more key animators than they could list per episode, let me tell you: you didn’t actually want that, for many reasons. That said, I’m also not particularly comfortable with big companies like Aniplex getting away with hiding production problems like this. It’s perfectly understandable that they try to for PR reasons, but if their job is to appear fine then I’m going to make it part of mine to let fans know when things go wrong.
Not the brightest times for A-1 and Aniplex, who recently also saw the director Ryohei Takeshita recruiting animation directors and key animators for his project next season. Takeshita’s got respectable experience, but his major roles have been at Dogakobo where he would be surrounded by a fair number of strong animators. Having to lead Eromanga Sensei at the freelance-heavy A-1 and considering many acquaintances of his are busy, it’s easy to see how he’d struggle. One of anime’s many tales of hardships!
I suppose that the mystery now is whether the arc being broadcast ‘early’ will feature Ishihama’s opening sequence or not. He planned to finish it for winter after all!
EDIT: The special does feature it after all! Perhaps some unfinished cuts around the end, but it’s there. They went out of their way to prove this post right which is very kind of them.
Support us on Patreon for more analysis, translations, staff insight and industry news, and so that we can keep affording the increasing costs of this adventure. Thanks to everyone who’s allowed us to keep on expanding the site’s scope!
I wanted to be a deep & profound elitist and become interested in those sakugas and technicalities, but turns out reading too much into them bores me, especially since I don’t watch the right shows. So this series of shorter and more compressed writeups is perfect even for a plebeian like me.
May the gods of your choice bless you, Kevin ;_;
There’s more short form content coming, not as replacement of what we’d been doing but simply because the Patreon support increasing lets us write even more kinds of posts. So yeah, more stuff you can enjoy hopefully coming up! No shame in having preferences.
I love that the content here is so diverse, one of these days I’m seriously gonna register on Patreon and throw moneys at you (but first – excuses! – have to take care of my health).
Take care~
Seems like A-1 Pictures is slowly collapsing, they have to start to reduce the amount of anime produced or things are going to look dark for the studio on the next years, their production system is insane, basically created to produce more money at cost of quality, and production assistant’s lives, which is a very poor and greedy way IMO, producing more than they can to create the major amount of $$$ possible at a faster pace, but well, that’s the situation of the industry….
Wouldn’t Keiji Fujiwara’s illness also be part of the reason for its delay? He voices one of the main characters (Eugen, specifically).
Dubbing isn’t a bottleneck for production – you could even fully animate a show before voicing any line if you desired. The lack of finished footage for months and a new chief animation director coming to save the project tell you the issues were more fundamental. Have they actually said what they’ll do with his role though? I know he got replaced in Blue Exorcist (also A-1, sharing one of its chief ADs, but airing on the season it was slated for!).
He was replaced in Shin-chan a long time ago as well. I’m worried :<
But yeah, voices can be changed even for established characters on a whim, I'm still salty over Jojo.
The Granblue Fantasy anime character designs still look overly detailed, as if they’re trying too hard to look like the game. Is this anime going to look okay, even with a less hellish schedule?
The shading seems very animation-unfriendly, so I’m not surprised that the animation directors in particular are having a hard time. I wonder whose decision it was, since Akai’s designs are usually better than this and way more stylized. Maybe he bailed as Chief AD after seeing the hellish work he’d have to pull off to supervise that.
Is it really a fault of poor planing? Why would Akira T, in your example, take on GBF in addition to BLue Exorcist and Natsume, unless studios are simply assigning folks stuff and they have no say so on if they can and cant do it?
-I assume anime delay will be added to this years running list of GBF’s monthly struggles, like someone was keeping track of in 2016. Maybe we can get ApoloGems 🙁
Chief animation direction is a big deal for animators, one of the best paid roles (often surpassing directors themselves). Unless they’re extremely sure they can’t handle it, chances are that they’ll say yes. Takata might have agreed to both before the projects were given dates assuming the producers would know better than schedule them at the same, or maybe it was after that had been decided but they really insisted. Either way, the funny thing about this is that the new Chief animation director was added so silently that some sites published the delay news while still listing the old… Read more »